How to Reinvent Yourself in Midlife by Changing Your Identity First

 

If you've looked around at your life lately and thought, I have everything I wanted, so why don't I feel like myself? this conversation is for you.

I'm joined by Ellen Baker, novelist and founder of The Next Chapter Studio, to talk about reinventing yourself in midlife by doing something most of us have completely backwards: choosing your identity before you have proof you're there.

 

This is for you if you've been thinking:

  • I've worked hard to get here. Why am I still not happy?

  • I don't feel like myself anymore and I don't know why.

  • I'm exhausted from doing all the things but I don't know how to stop.

  • I feel like I’m just going through the motions of life.

  • I want to step into who I'm becoming, but I keep waiting to feel ready.

 

Prefer to listen? Press play below:

Or listen on:

Apple Podcasts | Spotify

Why the Identity That Got You Here Won't Get You There

So many midlife women hit a point where life looks successful on the outside and something still feels off. Ellen calls this living from an outdated identity. Many of us adopted patterns to survive: people-pleasing, overworking, over-functioning, putting everyone else first, not speaking our truth. These patterns worked. They got us here. But at some point, they stop fitting. You don't want to live this way anymore. The question is not just what to do differently, but who to be.


The Author's Approach to Identity Change

Ellen's insight comes directly from her work as a novelist. Before writing a word, she decides who the character needs to be in order to arrive at the desired outcome. She argues we can do exactly the same thing in our own lives. Instead of waiting until we feel like the next version of ourselves, we decide who that person is first, and start acting accordingly. The story shifts because the character shifts.


"I Choose To": The Language Shift That Gives You Agency Right Now

Before you change a single behavior, there is one language shift that can change your relationship to your choices immediately. Replace "I have to" with "I choose to." Even when your actions stay the same, the shift from obligation to agency is real. Ellen teaches this as one of the first tools in her method. It reconnects you to your own authority over your life.


You Don't Have to Earn a New Identity Before You Claim It

This is the most counterintuitive part of Ellen's framework. We have been conditioned to believe that achievements unlock identities. You become a VP after the promotion. You deserve a vacation after the deadline. Ellen says it's backwards. You choose the identity first, and the evidence follows. The achievement is the outcome of the identity, not the other way around. This applies to every domain: career, relationships, self-worth.


How to Tell If a New Identity Is Truly Yours (Not Just a Performance)

There is a fine line, Ellen acknowledges, between an identity that is genuinely right and one you are just performing. Her answer comes back to the body. When you bring your energy in, breathe, and tune in, your body knows the truth. You may feel peace, expansion, or a sense of ease. You may feel chills or a release of tension you had stopped noticing. That is the signal.


The "What If?" Question That Makes It Possible

When it feels too hard to simply claim a new identity outright, Ellen recommends asking a question instead. What if I were a VP right now? What would she do? The question opens the door to new behavior without requiring belief. And once you do the brave thing, your brain gets evidence. That was safe. I made it. Let me try that again. The identity builds from action, and the question makes the first action possible.


What Actually Changes When You Step Into a New Identity

Change is gradual. Ellen is direct about this. The belief shift can happen quickly, but behavioral change takes time. Old habits run deep. The most important thing is to notice: notice when you could have chosen differently and didn't. That noticing is progress. And over time, the noticing becomes choosing differently.


How an Identity Shift Ripples Into Your Relationships

Stepping into a new identity doesn't just affect you. It ripples into every relationship you have. Partners, children, friends, coworkers. Ellen's reassurance: the people who truly care about you will ultimately be relieved. You will be less resentful. More honest. More aligned. And that benefits everyone in your orbit.

FAQs

How do I reinvent myself in midlife without losing who I am?

Ellen's answer: reinvention isn't about losing yourself, it's about dropping the beliefs and patterns that are no longer serving you. You are not trying to become someone unrecognizable. You are trying to become more yourself. The parts of you that are truest, most authentic, most alive. Those do not go away. They get more room.

Why do I feel stuck in midlife even when my life looks successful?

This is often a sign that the identity you adopted to get where you are is no longer the identity that fits. The over-functioning, people-pleasing, not-speaking-your-truth version of you was effective. It got you here. But at some point it stops fitting. That gap between what you have and how you feel is the signal.

How do I know which new identity is right for me?

Ellen says the body knows. When you bring your energy in, breathe deeply, and check how a new belief feels in your body, you can sense whether it is aligned. Look for a feeling of peace, expansion, or relief. That is the signal that you are on the right track. If you want guidance for how to tune into your body, try my private podcast custom created to help midlife women feel like themselves again.  

What does it mean to embody a new identity?

It means making choices from a new identity before you have proof it is real. Starting to act the way the next-level version of you would act. Asking, what would she do? And then doing it. The embodiment comes from the action, not the other way around.

How do identity shifts affect relationships?

They ripple out. When you stop people-pleasing, stop saying yes when you mean no, stop acting from resentment, the people around you will feel the change. Ellen says the people who love you will ultimately benefit. The transition may feel uncomfortable at first. But a version of you that is more aligned, more honest, and less resentful is a gift to everyone in your life.

Meet Ellen Baker:

After early success as a novelist with Random House, Ellen Baker spent a decade navigating divorce, rejection, a solo cross-country move, and reinvention before her third novel, The Hidden Life of Cecily Larson, became HarperCollins’ Lead Read for Winter 2024 and was featured in People and Woman’s World.

Her fourth novel, Summerland Cove, is new in June 2026.

With a passion for life stories and reinvention, Ellen is also the founder of The Next Chapter Studio, where she helps women rewrite the internal beliefs that shape how they show up in their lives so they can author a next chapter they love.

 


🎧 Other Episodes You’ll Love:

I Checked All the Boxes, So Why Am I Still Unsatisfied?

Why High-Performing Midlife Women Get Stuck at Director Level (and How to Break Through to VP)



Like what you hear?

➕ Follow Midlife Advice on Apple podcasts, Spotify or YouTube for more super smart and slightly sassy midlife conversations that blend science, intuition, and zero BS.

⭐️ Please share this episode with a friend, drop a 5-star rating and leave a review! That is the best way you can help me book more expert guests for us!





Disclaimer:

Belong Wellness and its members, managers, employees, contractors, and other agents or representatives are not licensed medical care providers and do not provide medical services or advice, including without limitation diagnosing, examining, preventing, treating, or curing any medical conditions. The information shared in this podcast is meant to be educational, not prescriptive. Please consult your medical doctor before making any changes to your diet or lifestyle. Further, the opinions of guests on this show do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Jessica or anyone affiliated with Belong Wellness.




For more midlife musings, follow me on Instagram @midlifeadvicepodcast

 
 

Hi! I’m your host, Jessica.

I am a trauma-informed breathwork facilitator, certified menopause coaching specialist, Pilates instructor, mom of two and long-time health nut here to help you feel informed, connected and badass during this wild stage of life.

 
 
 

Let’s connect!

Join my email list for more super smart and slightly sassy midlife antics.

Your first email will include a free 10-minute breathwork session to help you sleep like the queen you are!

Next
Next

Is Creatine Good for Women Over 40? A Functional Medicine Doctor Explains the Muscle, Brain, and Mood Benefits